To hire your first employee, decide whether the work calls for an employee at all, set up your employer tax and payroll basics, write a clear job posting, collect and track applicants in one place, interview everyone against the same criteria, and then make a written offer and handle the new-hire paperwork. This guide walks through each step for a small business owner without an HR team. It covers U.S. federal rules and points out where your state or city may add its own. It is general information, not legal or tax advice.
Before you hire: the right time and the right role
Here is the whole process in seven steps:
- Decide on the role. Employee or contractor, and the outcomes you expect.
- Set the budget. Count the full cost, not just pay.
- Set up the legal basics. EIN, payroll, insurance and state registrations.
- Write the job posting. The work, the pay and how to apply.
- Find candidates. Use more than one channel.
- Screen and interview. The same criteria for everyone.
- Offer and onboard. A written offer, the paperwork and a planned first week.
Employee or contractor
Whether someone is an employee or an independent contractor is a legal question, and there is more than one test. For federal taxes, the IRS looks at behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship, and it says no single factor decides the answer. You have to look at the whole relationship, especially your right to direct and control how the work is done. Federal wage-and-hour law (the Fair Labor Standards Act, enforced by the Department of Labor) uses its own test, and many states apply different tests again for unemployment insurance, workers' compensation and wage laws. A worker can be a contractor under one test and an employee under another.
A job title, a 1099 or a signed contractor agreement does not settle the question on its own, and neither does the schedule or how long the work lasts. If you are unsure, the IRS offers Form SS-8 for an official federal tax determination, though it can take months. An accountant or an employment attorney can review your situation under your state's rules. The SBA warns that misclassifying an employee can mean back taxes, penalties, benefits and wage reimbursement.
Define the job and the outcomes you expect
Write the role as results, not just tasks. "Answer calls" is a task. "Return every customer message within one business day" is an outcome you can check. List a handful of outcomes and the skills the person needs on day one. You will reuse this list in your job posting and in your interview scorecard.
Budget beyond pay
Pay is only part of the cost. Plan for:
- Social Security and Medicare. The employer pays 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare on an employee's wages, and withholds the same amounts from the employee's pay. Social Security applies only up to an annual wage base, which the IRS lists as $184,500 for 2026. Medicare has no wage base limit.
- Federal unemployment tax (FUTA). Only the employer pays FUTA; it is not deducted from the employee's wages. It is reported on Form 940. Most employers pay both federal and state unemployment tax.
- State payroll costs. Depending on your state, these can include unemployment insurance, workers' compensation and, in a few states, disability insurance. The SBA lists disability coverage requirements in California, Hawaii, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island and Puerto Rico.
- Everything else. Equipment, training, any benefits you offer, payroll software or an accountant, and your own time.
Minimum wage. The federal minimum wage is $7.25 per hour. The Department of Labor notes that many states have their own minimum wage laws, and where a state law is more protective, employers must comply with both. Some cities and counties set their own rates too, so check the rate where the employee will actually work.
Get your legal and payroll basics in place
Rules differ by state, and this is not legal advice. Check with your state agencies, your accountant or an employment attorney before your first hire.
The SBA describes a basic payroll setup: get an EIN, find out whether you need state or local tax IDs, decide between an employee and a contractor, collect a W-4, set pay periods, choose how you will run payroll, and keep the required records. The federal items are:
- Employer Identification Number (EIN). You generally need one to hire employees. The IRS issues it free of charge, so do not pay a website for it.
- Form W-4. Ask each new employee for a signed Form W-4 when they start work. It tells you how much federal income tax to withhold.
- Form I-9. You must verify identity and work authorization for every new employee. You or your authorized representative must complete Section 2 within 3 business days of the employee's first day of work for pay. For example, if the employee starts on Monday, the deadline is Thursday. If the job lasts less than 3 days, Section 2 is due by the first day of work. Keep the form on file; you do not send it to the government.
- New hire reporting. Federal law requires you to report each new or rehired employee to the state where they work within 20 days of hire. States can set a shorter deadline, and you must follow your state's.
State items to check:
- Workers' compensation. For private employers this is run by each state, and the Department of Labor directs private-sector questions to your state workers' compensation board. States set their own rules on which employers must carry coverage, including thresholds and exemptions that can depend on headcount or industry, so confirm the rule in your state before your employee starts.
- State taxes and unemployment insurance. Ask your state revenue and workforce agencies about income tax withholding and registering for unemployment insurance.
- Workplace posters. Federal law requires certain posters, and the SBA notes they are free from the Department of Labor. States have their own posters too.
Write a job posting that attracts the right people
A good posting is specific, honest and easy to scan. Include:
- A plain job title that people actually search for.
- Location and work mode: on-site, hybrid or remote.
- Pay (a range is fine) and the hours.
- The outcomes from your role definition and a short list of must-haves.
- A line about your business and team.
- How to apply.
Describe the work, not the person you imagine doing it. The EEOC says it is illegal to publish a job ad that shows a preference for or discourages applicants because of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age (40 or older), disability or genetic information. Its example is an ad asking for "recent college graduates," which may discourage people over 40. How much of federal anti-discrimination law covers you depends on headcount (see Screen and interview), but writing every ad this way costs nothing.
Here is a short sample. The business, location and pay are fictional and only illustrate the format. They are not a guide to market pay.
Example only: Customer Support Specialist (full time, on-site) Pay: [your range] per hour, depending on experience.
We are a small home services company looking for the first voice our customers hear. You will answer calls and messages, book appointments and follow up so that no request waits more than one business day.
You are a good fit if you communicate clearly and stay organized on busy days. Scheduling software experience is a plus; we will train you on the rest.
To apply, send your resume and answer two short questions.
Where to find candidates
Use more than one channel and compare what each one brings.
- Your own network. Ask customers, suppliers, friends and other business owners. The EEOC cautions that relying only on word of mouth can produce a discriminatory hiring pattern, so use it alongside other channels.
- Job boards. Post on the boards that fit your industry and area.
- Social media and your website. Share the job link and link a careers page from your site.
- Paid campaigns. If the free channels do not bring enough applicants, ads on Meta, LinkedIn or TikTok can reach people who are not browsing job boards. CruitUp offers these campaigns as an optional paid service; the applicant tracking system itself stays free.
If you can, use a separate link for each channel so you can see where your applicants come from.
Keep applicants organized
Once applications start arriving, you need to know who applied, who got a reply and who is waiting on a decision. An inbox or a spreadsheet can make this hard to track. A recruitment pipeline gives every applicant a visible stage, for example Applied, Screening, Interview, Offer and Hired, and you move them along as they progress.
CruitUp is a free applicant tracking system built for small businesses. The plan is free forever, with unlimited jobs, applicants and users. It includes:
- A kanban board for each job, so you can see every applicant's stage at a glance.
- Application forms with your own custom questions.
- Knockout questions that filter out applicants who do not meet a must-have, such as a required license.
- Automatic replies, so every applicant hears back.
- A career page that lists your open jobs.
Screen and interview
Decide your criteria before you read the first application. Write down your must-haves and what a strong answer looks like for each, then use the same list for everyone.
- Quick screen. Check each application against your must-haves.
- Short phone or video call. Confirm availability, pay expectations and interest.
- Structured interview. Ask every candidate the same questions, based on your outcomes, and score each answer right after the interview.
Keep questions job-related. The federal anti-discrimination laws the EEOC enforces depend on how many employees you have: the equal pay law applies from one employee, most of the other laws from 15, and the federal age law from 20. The EEOC also notes that state and local anti-discrimination laws may apply to your business, and some of them cover much smaller employers. Treating every applicant consistently is the safe default at any size. Under the federal rules, the EEOC says that in general you cannot request medical or genetic information from applicants.
When you decide not to move someone forward, tell them. A short, polite email is enough.
Make the offer and onboard
Call your top candidate first, then confirm in writing. A simple offer letter states the title, start date, pay, hours, who they report to and any conditions, such as a background check.
If you use a background check company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires you to give the candidate a written notice in a stand-alone document and get their written permission before you get the report. If you then decide against the person based on the report, there are notice steps before and after that decision. Some states and cities add their own rules on background checks.
Then plan the first week so your new hire is not left guessing:
- By the first day: the employee completes and signs Section 1 of Form I-9 (no later than the first day of work for pay) and gives you a signed Form W-4.
- Within 3 business days of the first day of work: you complete Section 2 of Form I-9.
- Within your state's deadline (20 days at most under federal law): file the new hire report.
- Week one: introduce the team, set a few early goals and schedule a check-in.
- Early on: put up the required federal and state workplace posters.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Assuming a contract makes someone a contractor. Classification depends on the actual working relationship, and federal and state tests differ.
- Budgeting only for pay. Employer payroll taxes, FUTA, state unemployment insurance and workers' compensation where required all add to the cost.
- Leaving pay out of the posting. Stating pay helps applicants decide whether to apply.
- Losing track of applicants. Keep every applicant in one place with a clear stage.
- Skipping the paperwork. A missing W-4, a late I-9 or a missed new hire report can cause problems later.
FAQ
How much does it cost to hire your first employee?
More than the pay. Add the employer share of Social Security (6.2%, up to the annual wage base) and Medicare (1.45%), federal unemployment tax, state unemployment insurance, workers' compensation where your state requires it, equipment, any benefits and the time you spend hiring and training. An accountant can estimate the total for your state and role.
Do I need an HR person to hire my first employee?
No, it is not a legal requirement. A payroll provider or accountant can handle tax filings, your state agencies can answer state questions, and an employment attorney can review anything unusual.
How long does hiring take?
It depends on the role, your area and the job market, so there is no standard answer. Build in time for posting, screening, interviews and the candidate's notice period, and plan the paperwork deadlines above around the actual start date.
Should my first hire be an employee or a contractor?
It depends on the actual working relationship, not on what you call it. The IRS, the Department of Labor and your state may each apply a different test, and no single factor such as schedule or length of the work decides it. If you are unsure, talk to an accountant or employment attorney, or ask the IRS for a determination with Form SS-8.
Next up: choosing your hiring tool. Your first job post may bring in more applications than an inbox can comfortably handle. In our next guide, Best Free ATS for Small Business, we compare free applicant tracking systems and what to look for before you pick one.